Executive Summary

This report examines the impact of minimum wage increases on the restaurant industry in New Mexico, utilizing publicly available data from government agencies, industry associations, and academic research. The analysis reveals a complex landscape where minimum wage policies interact with various economic factors, influencing labor costs, employment levels, and business operations. While the New Mexico Restaurant Association has voiced strong concerns about the potential negative effects of significant minimum wage hikes, citing increased labor costs and potential job losses, the empirical evidence from academic studies presents a mixed picture. Some research suggests negative employment effects, particularly in the tipped sector, while others indicate minimal or no significant impact. Employment in the broader leisure and hospitality sector in New Mexico has shown recovery to pre-pandemic levels, but specific trends within the restaurant industry require closer examination. Wage data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) indicate varying average wages across different restaurant occupations and regions within the state. Local minimum wage ordinances in cities like Albuquerque, Santa Fe, and Las Cruces add further complexity to the analysis. Ultimately, the impact of minimum wage increases on the restaurant industry in New Mexico is multifaceted, with businesses employing various strategies to adapt to rising labor costs in an evolving economic environment.

Introduction

Minimum wage legislation in New Mexico has undergone several changes in recent years, reflecting a broader national discussion on fair wages and economic equity. The current state minimum wage stands at $12.00 per hour, a rate that was reached in January 2023 following a series of incremental increases.1 For employees who customarily receive tips, the minimum cash wage is $3.00 per hour, with employers required to ensure that the combination of tips and wages equals or exceeds the standard minimum wage of $12.00 per hour.1

Adding to this framework are local minimum wage ordinances in several New Mexico cities and counties, which in some cases exceed the state mandate. For instance, Albuquerque has its own ordinance, although the state’s $12.00 per hour rate currently prevails.1 Santa Fe City and County have historically maintained higher minimum wages 1, with rates often surpassing $14.00 per hour. Las Cruces also has a local ordinance with scheduled increases.1 Looking ahead, there have been proposals for further increases, such as the fiercely contested measure to raise the state minimum wage to $17 per hour by 2026, which has generated significant opposition from business advocates.24 The complexity of these regulations suggests that the impact on the restaurant industry may vary across different regions and business types within New Mexico.

The restaurant industry holds a vital position within the New Mexico economy. It employs a substantial workforce, with over 90,000 individuals contributing to the sector, and generates over $5.3 billion in annual sales.25 Restaurants are also a significant driver of the state’s overall economic activity, with each dollar spent in these establishments contributing $1.69 to the New Mexico economy in 2022.26 In the same year, the industry accounted for 11% of the total employment within the state.26 Notably, the 76,100 jobs in eating and drinking places constitute the majority of the total restaurant and foodservice workforce in New Mexico.26 Given this significant economic footprint, understanding the effects of minimum wage policies on the restaurant industry is crucial for assessing the overall economic health and labor market dynamics of New Mexico. This report aims to analyze the impact of minimum wage increases on the restaurant industry in New Mexico, focusing on publicly available data related to employment and wages at both the statewide and local levels, particularly within Albuquerque.

Analysis of Minimum Wage Increases on the New Mexico Restaurant Industry

The prospect of minimum wage increases in New Mexico has elicited strong reactions from the restaurant industry. The New Mexico Restaurant Association has been vocal in its opposition to substantial hikes, arguing that they could have devastating consequences for businesses already grappling with challenges such as inflation.24 Carol Wight, CEO of the Association, has highlighted the struggles many restaurants face and the potential for significant labor cost increases, citing an example where a proposed $17 per hour minimum wage could cost a restaurant with just 20 full-time employees nearly $400,000 in increased labor expenses.24 These concerns extend to the potential elimination of the lower tipped wage, which the industry argues is essential for the current business model.29

In response to rising labor costs, restaurants may consider various strategies to mitigate the impact on their bottom line. These can include raising menu prices across the board to offset increased payroll expenses.8 Another potential response is to streamline operations, which might involve adjusting staffing levels, trimming seasonal employees, or even considering layoffs.8 Investing in technology to automate certain tasks or improve efficiency is another avenue some restaurants might explore.8 Additionally, businesses might choose to reduce their operating hours or modify their service models, potentially shifting towards more counter service options to reduce the reliance on tipped staff.8 Focusing on retaining current employees through better compensation and benefits can also be a strategy to combat the high costs associated with employee turnover.8 The National Restaurant Association has also expressed concerns that significant minimum wage increases could lead to employers cutting back on worker hours and/or eliminating positions, ultimately driving up consumer costs in a labor-intensive industry like restaurants.31

The debate around minimum wage in the restaurant industry is closely intertwined with the issue of tipped wages and the tip credit. In New Mexico, as in many other states, employers are allowed to take a tip credit, paying tipped employees a lower base wage as long as their tips bring their total hourly earnings up to at least the standard minimum wage.3 However, proposals like House Bill 246 have suggested eliminating this lower wage for tipped workers, which has faced strong opposition from the restaurant industry, arguing it would be financially damaging.24 Interestingly, some tipped employees themselves have expressed concerns about such changes, fearing potential job losses or a reduction in their overall earnings if restaurants were to move away from a tipping model.24 The interplay between the standard minimum wage and the tipped wage system adds a significant layer of complexity to the analysis of minimum wage impacts on the restaurant sector.

Academic research on the effects of minimum wage increases on the restaurant industry provides a range of findings. Some studies conducted in other locations, such as Santa Fe, New Mexico, have suggested that minimum wage increases can lead to job losses, particularly among less-educated workers.32 Research on tipped minimum wages has also indicated the potential for reduced employment in the full-service restaurant sector due to wage hikes.33 However, other academic works have found minimal to modest job losses or even no significant impact on restaurant employment following minimum wage increases.30 For example, a study analyzing minimum wage increases in Las Cruces, New Mexico, projected some job losses in the Accommodation and Food Services sector, but also noted increases in personal income for low-wage families.38 Research focusing on a local minimum wage ordinance in the Albuquerque/Bernalillo region of New Mexico found that a 10 percent increase in the minimum wage could increase earnings in the restaurant sector.46 This variation in findings underscores the importance of examining the specific context of New Mexico and considering the methodologies and data used in different studies.

Statewide Restaurant Industry Employment Data

Data from the New Mexico Department of Workforce Solutions (NMDWS) offers insights into the state’s labor market, including the restaurant sector. The NMDWS collects, analyzes, and publishes information on economic conditions and trends, such as job growth and wage levels.47 Reports on the state of the workforce produced by the department highlight employment trends across various industries.48 Notably, in August 2022, Governor Michelle Lujan Grisham announced that New Mexico’s leisure and hospitality jobs had surpassed pre-pandemic levels, reaching 100.6% of the jobs recorded before the pandemic.52 Additionally, the number of food establishments in the state also exceeded pre-pandemic figures during this period.52 However, the Governor’s office was using the number of food service establishment permits issued which includes schools and non-restaurant related food service establishment. While this indicates a recovery in the broader hospitality sector, specific data from the NMDWS detailing the employment trends within the restaurant industry before and after the recent minimum wage increases would provide a more targeted analysis of the policy’s impact. The overall recovery from the pandemic could potentially mask some of the longer-term effects of wage policies on the restaurant industry’s employment levels.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) also provides comprehensive data on employment in the food services and drinking places sector in New Mexico. The BLS’s Current Employment Statistics (CES) program publishes monthly estimates of nonagricultural wage and salary employment by industry.53 The food services and drinking places subsector, as defined by the BLS, encompasses full-service restaurants, limited-service eating places, special food services, and drinking places (alcoholic beverages).54 According to BLS data from May 2023, 8.7% of all jobs in the United States were in food preparation and serving related occupations.55 Analyzing historical BLS data specifically for New Mexico could reveal trends in employment within the restaurant sector over time and potentially highlight any correlations with the implementation of minimum wage increases. This standardized data source allows for comparisons across different periods and regions.

Data from the National Restaurant Association indicates that there were 94,200 restaurant and foodservice jobs in New Mexico.28 More recent data from the association shows 90,100 such jobs in 2022.26 Examining the changes in these employment figures over time, particularly around the dates of minimum wage increases, could offer insights into the potential impact. However, it is important to acknowledge that various economic factors beyond minimum wage policies can also influence employment levels in the restaurant industry.

Statewide Restaurant Industry Wage Data

The BLS provides detailed data on average hourly and annual wages for a wide range of restaurant and food service occupations in New Mexico. This information is available by occupation for the nation, specific regions, individual states, and many metropolitan and nonmetropolitan areas.56 According to BLS data from May 2023, the mean hourly wage for food preparation and serving related occupations in Santa Fe, New Mexico, was $17.02.57 For Food Service Managers in New Mexico, the mean hourly wage was $29.89 in May 2023 58, with a median hourly wage of $27.67.58 Tracking these wage levels over time can help to assess whether minimum wage increases have translated into broader wage growth within the restaurant sector across different occupations.

The New Mexico Department of Workforce Solutions also collects and may provide wage data for the restaurant industry. The NMDWS’s Labor Market and Economic Research (LASER) website offers access to various labor market statistics, including occupational wages.60 Examining this potential source of data could offer a more localized and detailed perspective on wage trends within the state’s restaurant industry, complementing the national-level data provided by the BLS.

The state minimum wage in New Mexico has seen incremental increases, reaching 12.00per hour in 2023. By comparing the growth rate of average restaurant wages—using data from the BLS and potentially NMDWS—with the timing and scale of minimum wage increases, we can identify possible correlations. This analysis could reveal whether wage adjustments primarily affect the lowest-paid workers or if they create broader upward pressure across the restaurant industry. To provide clearer insight into current wage levels in New Mexico’s restaurant sector, the following table presents average hourly and annual wages for key occupations, based on BLS data from May 2023

    Occupation                  Mean Hourly Wage         Mean Annual Wage ($)         Source 

Food Service Managers       29.89                                        62,170                          BLS 58

Cooks, Restaurant       Data Unavailable                  Data Unavailable                 BLS 86 

Wait Staff                      Data Unavailable                  Data Unavailable                  BLS 87

Hosts Staff                    Data Unavailable                  Data Unavailable                  BLS 88

Note: Specific wage data for Cooks (Restaurant), Waiters and Waitresses, and Hosts and Hostesses in New Mexico for May 2023 was not directly available in the provided snippets. This data can be accessed through the BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics website.

Localized Restaurant Industry Data for Albuquerque

Focusing on Albuquerque, New Mexico, BLS data provides insights into the localized employment trends within the restaurant industry. According to BLS data from May 2023, food preparation and serving related occupations constituted 9.3% of the total employment in the Albuquerque Metropolitan Statistical Area.61 This local employment share is slightly higher than the national average of 8.7% for the same occupational group. Earlier data from September 2019 indicated that total private employment in Albuquerque was up by 1.9%, with the leisure and hospitality sector being a significant contributor to this growth.62 Examining employment data specific to the restaurant industry in Albuquerque over a longer period, particularly around the times of minimum wage changes, could reveal if local trends deviate from the statewide patterns. These deviations might be attributable to Albuquerque’s unique economic conditions or the influence of its local minimum wage ordinance.

BLS data also offers information on the average wages for restaurant occupations within Albuquerque. In May 2023, the mean hourly wage for food preparation and serving related occupations in Albuquerque was $15.54 61, which is lower than the statewide average for this category. For Food Service Managers in Albuquerque during the same period, the mean hourly wage was $31.08.63 Comparing these average wage levels in Albuquerque with the statewide averages can indicate whether the local labor market or cost of living factors in the city influence compensation in its restaurant industry.

Albuquerque has its own minimum wage ordinance; however, the current state minimum wage of $12.00 per hour supersedes it.1 Starting January 1, 2025, the minimum wage for tipped employees in Albuquerque is set at $7.20 per hour.7 Analyzing the trends in wage and employment data in Albuquerque in relation to these local minimum wage policies could help to isolate the impact of these policies on the city’s restaurant industry compared to the rest of New Mexico, where different local ordinances may be in effect.

Insights from Academic and Industry Sources

Academic institutions and research organizations in New Mexico have also contributed to the understanding of the restaurant industry and the potential impacts of minimum wage. Researchers at the University of New Mexico (UNM) have examined various aspects of restaurant labor, including issues of race, class, and gender inequalities, as well as the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on the industry.64 While not directly focused on minimum wage impacts, this research provides valuable context regarding the labor dynamics and challenges within the state’s restaurant sector. New Mexico State University (NMSU) has a Food Technology program that assists food producers and may have conducted research relevant to the broader food service industry.66 Additionally, studies on food localization in New Mexico highlight the growing interest in local food systems, which can indirectly affect restaurants.68 This localized academic work can offer perspectives that complement broader national studies on minimum wage.

Industry associations, such as the New Mexico Restaurant Association (NMRA), play a crucial role in representing the interests of restaurant owners and operators in the state. The NMRA actively engages in discussions and advocacy related to wage issues, including minimum wage.2 Carol Wight, the CEO of the NMRA, has frequently voiced concerns about the potential negative impacts of proposed minimum wage hikes on the state’s restaurants.24 The association also provides its members with resources and information regarding wage and hour rules and regulations.2 Similarly, the New Mexico Hospitality Association tracks industry trends and legislative developments that can affect restaurants, often collaborating with the NMRA on issues of mutual concern.23 The reports and statements from these industry associations offer valuable insights into the perceived impacts of minimum wage increases on business operations, profitability, and employment from the perspective of those directly involved in the restaurant sector.

Discussion of Broader Economic Factors and Business Responses

The impact of minimum wage increases on the restaurant industry in New Mexico does not occur in a vacuum. Broader economic factors such as inflation, the overall cost of living in the state, and the general economic climate all play a role in shaping these effects. For instance, some reports suggest that inflation has already posed significant challenges for restaurants in New Mexico.24 Minimum wage policies are often intended to help workers keep pace with the rising cost of living.6 Interestingly, despite recent minimum wage increases in New Mexico, the state’s labor market has remained tight, partly attributed to the effects of high inflation.85 This interplay of economic forces can influence both the necessity for and the ultimate impact of minimum wage adjustments on the restaurant industry and its workforce.

Restaurants in New Mexico, like those elsewhere, have adopted various strategies to navigate the challenges posed by increased labor costs. One common approach is to make adjustments to their menus, which can include raising prices on certain items or implementing a service charge to help offset higher payroll expenses.8 Some restaurants may also choose to trim their menus, focusing on the most popular and profitable items to reduce inventory costs and waste.9 Investing in technology, such as handheld point-of-sale systems or online ordering platforms, can help to streamline operations, improve efficiency, and potentially reduce the need for as many staff members.8 Another important strategy for restaurants is to focus on staff retention. By offering competitive wages, benefits, and a positive work environment, businesses can reduce the high costs associated with employee turnover.8 Understanding these diverse operational and strategic responses of restaurants to rising labor costs is essential for a comprehensive assessment of the overall impact of minimum wage increases on the industry’s long-term sustainability and its capacity to provide employment opportunities.

Conclusion

The analysis of publicly available data reveals a complex and sometimes contradictory picture regarding the impact of minimum wage increases on the restaurant industry in New Mexico. While industry associations have expressed significant concerns about potential negative consequences such as increased labor costs and job losses 24, academic research presents a range of findings, with some studies suggesting negative employment effects, particularly in the tipped sector 32, while others indicate minimal or no significant impact.30 Statewide employment in the leisure and hospitality sector has recovered to pre-pandemic levels 52, but specific trends within the restaurant industry require further scrutiny. Wage data from the BLS show varying average wages across different restaurant occupations and regions 15, and local minimum wage ordinances in cities like Albuquerque, Santa Fe, and Las Cruces add another layer of complexity.1 Restaurants have employed various strategies, including price adjustments and technology investments, to adapt to rising labor costs in an evolving economic landscape.8

Recommendations

Based on this analysis, several areas warrant further investigation to gain a more comprehensive understanding of the long-term effects of minimum wage increases on the restaurant industry in New Mexico. More localized studies focusing on the specific impacts in different regions of the state, considering the variations in local minimum wage ordinances and economic conditions, would be valuable. It would also be beneficial to explore the long-term effects of the minimum wage increases that have already been implemented in recent years, as the immediate aftermath might not fully reflect the sustained impacts. Further research into the effects of the tip credit system in New Mexico and the potential implications of proposed changes or alternatives to this system is also recommended. Additionally, examining the relationship between minimum wage levels, average wage growth across different restaurant occupations, and employee turnover rates could provide deeper insights into the overall labor market dynamics within the industry.