• Home
  • About NMRA
    • We Are the Restaurant Industry in New Mexico
    • Staff List
    • BLOG from the CEO and Chair
    • NMRA Annual Sponsors
    • Contact Us
  • Membership
    • Member Login
    • Restaurants Join Now
    • Members Return on Investment
    • Associate Membership
      • Advertise with NMRA
    • Online Buyers Guide
    • Members-Only Savings
  • Classes
    • Online Alcohol Server Training
    • Alcohol Server Certification Classroom
    • Food Safety Certification
    • ManageFirst
    • Webinars
  • Advocacy
    • Legislative Issues 2019
      • Legislative Alerts
      • Legislative Tracker
    • Legal and Regulatory Alerts
      • Press Releases
      • Member Newsletter Archive
    • Scams
  • Resources
    • Restaurant Resource Links
    • NM AGD Regulations
    • New Mexico Food Safety Regulations
    • Minimum Wage in New Mexico
    • FAQ’s
    • Toolkit
  • Foundation
    • Scholarships
    • ProStart Program
  • Classifieds
    • Job Bank
  • Calendar
    • Events

NMRA

Helping Restaurants in New Mexico be Successful

Tip Policies in New Mexico as of July 2017

July 26, 2017 by Wendy Hughes

On July 20th the U.S. Department of Labor signaled its plan to rescind the tip-pooling restrictions put in place under the Obama Administration. It stated it will issue a “Notice of Proposed Rulemaking,”specifically, “in this Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, the Department will propose to rescind the current restrictions on tip pooling by employers that pay tipped employees the full minimum wage directly.” This notice does not immediately change the law, but is the first step in future change.

Below is an analysis of a recent 10th circuit court ruling on the ownership of tips when an employee is paid above the minimum wage.
Facts:
Plaintiff Marlow (employee) sued her employer, The New Food Guy, Inc. dba Relish Catering (employer) for alleged violations of The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) requires a minimum wage of $7.25 plus time and a half for overtime. Relish paid Marlow $12 per hour and $18 per hour for overtime. Employer retained all tips paid by customers and did not share any amount of the tips with employee. Marlow claims her employer is obligated to give her a share of all tips paid by customers. Marlow’s argument relies on FLSA tip-credit provision that applies to employers who satisfy their minimum wage obligations with tips retained by their employees, and on a regulation promulgated by the Department of Labor (DOL).
Questions Presented:
1. Does an employer violate the FLSA tip-credit provision when it pays its employees a set wage that is greater that the minimum wage but the employer retains all tips paid by its customers?
2. Does the DOL have the authority to promulgate regulations that make tips the property of the employee even if an employer pays its employees a set wage that is greater than the minimum wage and has not taken the tip credit?
Short Answer:
In the 10th Circuit, an employer does not violate the FLSA tip-credit provision when it pays its employees a set wage greater than minimum wage. The DOL did not have the authority to promulgate the FLSA tip-credit provision to make tips the property of the employee if the employee receives a set wage greater than minimum wage.
Tip-Credit Provision
In general, the FLSA’s concern is with the wage payments employees receive, and not with tracing the source of the money used by the employer to pay the wage. The employer has the right to make it a condition of employment that it would retain or own all tips. The tip-credit provision does not extend to this scenario. The provision gives employers of “tipped employees” the option of paying a reduced hourly wage of $2.13 as long as the employees receive enough tips to bring them to the $7.25 minimum. If the employee does not receive enough tips, the employer pays the difference. Excess tips would also go to the employee. Here, the employer never invoked the tip-credit provision in the first place because it paid Marlow a wage above the $7.25 minimum wage. That wage was not dependent on tips. All that the tip-credit provision does is permit a limited tip credit and then state what the employer must do if it wishes to take that credit. When employers do not take the credit, they must do what all employers must do – pay full minimum wage.
DOL Regulation
Congress empowered the DOL to promulgate necessary rules and regulations with regard to the FLSA. DOL sought to exercise this power through a regulation that stated “tips are the property of the employee whether or not employer has taken the tip credit.” Here, Marlow relied on this regulation, because on its face, it supports her position. However, the DOL did not have the authority to promulgate this regulation in the first place. Agencies may promulgate rules to fill “ambiguities” or “gaps” in statutes. Silence or gaps are undefined terms in a statute or a statutory directive to perform a task without giving detailed instructions. Here, there is no statutory language directing the DOL to regulate ownership of tips when an employer does not invoke the tip-credit provision. The text of the tip-credit provision limits tip restrictions to those employers who take the tip credit. By its clear language, the tip-credit provision applies only when the employer uses tips as a credit against minimum wage. It does not apply to employers who pay employees a set wage above the minimum wage. When the intent of the statute is clear and unambiguous as in the present case of the tip-credit provision, agencies must always defer to the unambiguous expressed intent of Congress. Thus, the DOL did not have the authority to promulgate its regulation concerning the the tip-credit provision because the clear language of the tip-credit provision is not ambiguous.
Takeaway for the NMRA:
New Mexico restaurants that pay employees a fixed wage above the set minimum wage and do not take advantage of the tip-credit have no obligation to share tips with employees and may retain all tips. In this situation, the tips belong to the restaurant and the employee is only entitled to receive his/her hourly wages. It is advisable that any restaurant include discussion of any such arrangements in its Employee Handbook as a best practice.

No Legal Advice Intended

The contents of this website are intended to convey general information only and not to provide legal advice or opinions.  The contents of this website, and the posting and viewing of the information on this website, should not be construed as, and should not be relied upon for, legal or tax advice in any particular circumstance or fact situation.  The information presented on this website may not reflect the most current legal developments.  Further, this website may contain technical inaccuracies or typographical errors.  No action should be taken in reliance on the information contained on this website and we disclaim all liability in respect to actions taken or not taken based on any or all of the contents of this site to the fullest extent permitted by law.  An attorney should be contacted for advice on specific legal issues.

New Mexico Restaurant Association, Inc. DOES NOT provide any legal advice and users of this web site should consult with their own lawyer for legal advice.

Share this...
Email this to someone
email
Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
Linkedin
Pin on Pinterest
Pinterest

Filed Under: Alerts, Legal and Regulatory Alerts, Legislative Alerts, Toolkit

Online Buyer’s Guide

Stay in the know!

FAQ’s

Serving Alcohol 101

Serving Alcohol 101

Have a few questions about serving alcohol in New Mexico?  We've got you covered! Here at NMRA, we answer a lot of calls and inquiries about alcohol service.  Maybe you've even taken one of our … [Read More...]

More Posts from this Category

Save Our Tips Petition Signers

Videos from NMRA

What Are the Secrets to Restaurant Success?

What Are the Secrets to Restaurant Success?

Check out this informative video with NMRA CEO, Carol Wight and Jeff Harrison with SwingPointMedia on making your restaurant more successful. Now are you ready to make your restaurant more successful? Check out our very helpful Restaurant Success Guide today! You can always contact Carol with any questions you may have at executive@nmrestaurants.org or call […]

The 2018 Hospitality Industry Award Winners

The 2018 Hospitality Industry Award Winners

The New Mexico Restaurant Association is pleased to announce the winners of the 2018 Hospitality Industry Awards that took place on Monday, September 10th at Embassy Suites in Downtown Albuquerque. Over 450 individuals attended this year’s 1920’s, Prohibition-era, Gatsby themed event which also recognized New Mexico’s “Most Wanted” Restaurant Neighbor, Chef, Manager, and also gave […]

More Posts from this Category

NMRA Annual Sponsors

Contact

New Mexico Restaurant Association
9201 Montgomery NE Suite 602
Albuquerque, NM 87111
505.343.9848
dining@nmrestaurants.org

Our Mission

Our mission is to empower the food and beverage industry by promoting and protecting common values and interests.

Our Vision

Through the active participation of our members, NMRA will be the leading advocate and invaluable resource for education, political action, information and services for our industry and the community we serve.

Copyright © 2019 · by The New Mexico Restaurant Association · Website Powered by: Swell Host